The Strategic Imperative for Cryptographic Reform in the U.S. Government

Public Sector
February 18, 2025

The rapid evolution of quantum computing presents an existential challenge to existing cryptographic frameworks, necessitating urgency to strengthen security measures. As global advancements in quantum research accelerate, particularly in China, it is crucial for both the private and public sectors to reassess and reinforce cryptographic defenses. Without proactive measures, vulnerabilities in cryptographic management could expose sensitive data, disrupt critical operations, and impact critical infrastructure.

The Current State of Cryptographic Vulnerabilities

Despite growing awareness of cybersecurity threats, cryptographic vulnerabilities remain an often-overlooked aspect of risk management. Issues such as expired digital certificates, inadequate key management, and unencrypted credentials increase the risk of security breaches and operational disruptions. According to the Ponemon-Sullivan Privacy Report, unplanned outages due to expired certificates can drive complications that cost an individual organization as much as $67.2 million over a two-year period. Extrapolating across industries, this translates into billions of dollars in economic losses annually, underscoring the urgent need for comprehensive cryptographic oversight and digital identity management to mitigate financial and operational risks.

Zero Trust Architecture (ZTA) has emerged as a fundamental cybersecurity strategy, emphasizing strict access controls and authentication mechanisms. However, many security solutions focus on identity verification and network segmentation while overlooking the cryptographic infrastructure that underpins these systems. Without a robust cryptographic foundation, even the most advanced security frameworks may remain susceptible to exploitation.

Addressing High-Priority Cryptographic Management Gaps

Current security standards, such as FedRAMP, emphasize the use of robust cryptographic algorithms like AES-256. However, they often fail to address the critical issue of proper cryptographic implementation. This oversight leads to poor key management practices, unnoticed certificate expirations, and insecure credential storage. The focus on using the right cryptography rather than using cryptography right fosters a false sense of security.

Most organizations lack comprehensive visibility into their cryptographic assets–keys are mismanaged, certificates expire without detection, and credentials are stored insecurely exposing vulnerabilities. This fragmented approach to cryptographic management results in significant security gaps, leaving systems vulnerable to exploitation. The consequences include financial losses from certificate outages, data breaches due to credential leaks, and critical vulnerabilities within national security infrastructure. For instance, in 2024, a ransomware attack on Change Healthcare compromised sensitive data of over 100 million individuals, leading to a ransom payment. Similarly, the National Public Data breach exposed personal information of nearly 2.9 billion individuals, underscoring the extensive reach and potential consequences of such incidents. These events highlight the critical need for robust cryptographic measures to protect sensitive information and maintain operational integrity.

The Quantum Threat: A Catalyst for Change

China’s aggressive pursuit of quantum supremacy underscores the urgency of the situation. The development of cryptographically-relevant quantum computers capable of breaking public-key encryption (PKE) systems is not a distant threat but an imminent reality. Adversaries equipped with such technology could decrypt sensitive government communications, manipulate critical data, and disrupt essential services, posing an existential risk to our economy and national security.

Additionally, the risk extends beyond immediate threats—adversaries can intercept and store encrypted data today with the intent of decrypting it in the future using quantum capabilities. This "Store Now, Decrypt Later" (SNDL) strategy underscores the importance of adopting proactive cryptographic reforms to mitigate long-term risks.

Operational and Strategic Recommendations

To safeguard government IT systems and sensitive data against emerging cybersecurity threats, including AI-driven and quantum-based attacks, the following strategic initiatives must be implemented without delay:

  • Comprehensive Cryptographic Inventory: Conduct an immediate and thorough assessment of cryptographic elements across government agency networks to identify vulnerabilities and prevent impending breaches.
  • Implementation of Post-Quantum Cryptographic (PQC) Algorithms: Accelerate the adoption of PQC algorithms, as recommended by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), to protect against quantum-based decryption threats.
  • Cryptographic Agility: Develop and implement unified cryptography management systems capable of real-time responses to policy violations and evolving security threats.
  • Enhanced Regulatory Frameworks: Establish and enforce updated regulations that focus specifically on cryptographic management, including mandates for key lifecycle management, audit requirements, and breach reporting protocols.
  • Interagency Collaboration: Urgently foster cross-agency collaboration to share best practices and establish standardized approaches to cryptographic security. Agencies such as the Department of Homeland Security, U.S. Customs and Border Protection, the Defense Information Systems Agency (DISA), and the Department of Health and Human Services have already taken steps toward PQC readiness and must serve as models for broader implementation.

The Consequences of Inaction

Cryptographic security is not merely a technical consideration—it is an urgent and unavoidable security imperative. Every day that passes without addressing these vulnerabilities increases the risk of devastating consequences, including unauthorized access to classified information, disruptions to critical infrastructure, and an erosion of confidence in cybersecurity capabilities.

Quantum decryption, once a distant concern, is now an imminent operational threat. Given the complexity of government IT systems, a full transition to PQC could take a decade or more. Agencies cannot afford to wait. Without immediate and decisive action, they will be forced into reactive crisis management rather than proactive security enhancement.

The time to act is now. To ensure the protection of sensitive private and public sector data, communications, and national interests, agencies must adopt a unified and regulated approach to cryptographic management without further delay. Strengthening regulatory frameworks, enforcing best practices, and preparing for quantum-driven threats will determine whether government agencies can maintain a strategic security advantage—or suffer irreversible breaches. Cyber threats are evolving rapidly, and failure to act today will have lasting consequences tomorrow.

Further Reading

No items found.